The Edison, New Jersey, township council has stirred controversy by enacting new rules prohibiting the use of the American flag during public comment periods, labeling it a “prop.” The ordinance also imposes strict time limits on residents speaking at meetings, eliminates rebuttals, and bans offensive language, costumes, and disruptive behavior.
Critics argue the new policies are an attack on free speech and patriotism. During a recent meeting, resident Joel Bassoff held up an American flag while addressing the council, only to have Council President Nishith Patel declare he had violated the rules and forfeit his speaking time. When Bassoff persisted, he was removed from the meeting.
“The American flag and Constitution are not props,” said resident Maryann Hennessey. “To consider them as such is an insult to what they represent and to this country.”
Another resident, Sue Malone-Barber, accused the council of silencing dissent. “This is ludicrous, rude, and juvenile,” she said. “Residents won’t forget how they were treated. Flags, really a prop? You going to throw me out?”
The ordinance is seen by some as a way to suppress criticism of the council’s handling of local issues, including allegations of wasteful spending and neglect of community concerns. Opponents argue the restrictions are fueling public frustration rather than restoring order to meetings.
“This is a waste of taxpayer time,” Malone-Barber added. “Let it go. You’re only agitating people and making them more determined to push back.”
The council’s decision to equate the American flag with disruptive props has sparked widespread backlash, with many residents vowing to hold their local leaders accountable for what they see as a disrespectful and heavy-handed policy.
This dispute highlights ongoing tensions between government transparency, public expression, and efforts to maintain decorum in public forums.
