DHS considers a reality TV show where immigrants compete for American citizenship through contests across the nation, drawing both excitement and serious ethical concerns.
At a Glance
- A proposal for a reality show called “The American” would have immigrants compete for expedited U.S. citizenship
- The show concept was developed with Rob Worsoff, a producer known for “Duck Dynasty”
- Contestants would travel across America participating in cultural and historical challenges
- DHS spokesperson clarified Secretary Kristi Noem was unaware of the pitch and it hasn’t been approved
- Critics question whether turning citizenship into a competition undermines the dignity of the naturalization process
The American: A Citizenship Competition
A controversial proposal circulating within the Department of Homeland Security envisions a reality television show where immigrants compete for fast-tracked American citizenship. The show, titled “The American,” would feature pre-vetted immigrants traveling across the United States and participating in challenges related to American culture and history. The concept includes contestants arriving at Ellis Island before embarking on their journey through various regions of America, with themed challenges reflecting local traditions and historical significance of each area.
According to reports from multiple news outlets, the show would include 12 contestants, with those eliminated receiving consolation prizes such as airline miles, Starbucks gift cards, and even a lifetime supply of gasoline. The winner would receive the ultimate prize: American citizenship, with a swearing-in ceremony conducted on the steps of the U.S. Capitol building. Other contestants would reportedly receive advantages in their traditional citizenship applications.
Production Details and Celebrity Involvement
The show concept was developed with Rob Worsoff, a producer known for reality TV shows including “Duck Dynasty.” The pitch reportedly suggests potential hosts like Sofia Vergara, Mila Kunis, and Ryan Reynolds – all immigrants or children of immigrants who have achieved success in America. The production is seeking approval from streaming services like Netflix, though no platform has officially signed on to the project yet.
“I’m not affiliated with any political ideology. As an immigrant myself, I am merely trying to make a show that celebrates the immigration process, celebrate what it means to be American and have a national conversation about what it means to be American, through the eyes of the people who want it most.”, said Rob Worsoff.
The concept reflects a growing trend of television producers seeking collaboration with the Trump administration. Initial reports suggested DHS Secretary Kristi Noem was backing the proposal, adding to her controversial media-focused approach that has earned her criticism and the nickname “ICE Barbie” from some critics. However, DHS has since clarified that Secretary Noem was not involved in or aware of the pitch.
DHS Response and Clarification
Following media reports about the proposed show, DHS spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin issued statements clarifying the department’s position. She emphasized that Secretary Noem was unaware of the pitch, contradicting initial reports that suggested Noem had backed the concept. McLaughlin explained that DHS receives hundreds of television show pitches annually, ranging from documentaries about border operations to investigations of white-collar crime.
“This is completely false. @DailyMail’s ‘reporting’ is an affront to journalism. Secretary Noem has not ‘backed’ or even aware of the pitch of any scripted or reality show.”, said Tricia McLaughlin.
McLaughlin further explained that all television proposals undergo thorough vetting before receiving approval or denial, and clarified that this particular pitch has not yet been either approved or denied by DHS staff. Some reports initially suggested McLaughlin had expressed support for the concept with a comment that “I think it’s a good idea,” but this was later contextualized as being taken out of context or misattributed.
Public Reaction and Ethical Concerns
The proposal has generated significant debate about the ethics of turning the citizenship process into entertainment. Supporters suggest the show could celebrate immigration, showcase immigrant perspectives, and spark important national dialogue about American identity. They argue that highlighting the journeys of those who most desire citizenship could foster greater understanding and appreciation for the American dream. Critics, however, question whether transforming citizenship into a competition undermines the dignity and seriousness of the naturalization process.
The administration’s border policies have reportedly reduced illegal crossings significantly, according to DHS data. This reality show concept emerges against this backdrop of heightened attention to immigration issues. Whether “The American” will move forward from concept to production remains uncertain, as it requires not only DHS approval but also funding and a distribution platform willing to air what would undoubtedly be a controversial program in the current political climate.
